A brief history of coal mining in Clutton by L. J. Cunningham
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
The photograph in Fig. 4 comes from John Da Costa's collection.
The illustration on the front cover was drawn by Paul Marsh.
The illustration in Fig. 2 is from The Collier by A. R. Griffin.
INTRODUCTION
Geographically the parish of Clutton is situated ten miles south of Bristol and ten miles south-west of Bath. Geologically, Clutton is situated on the northern edge of the Somerset Coalfield. It is this geological position that has largely shaped much of Clutton's past. For nearly four centuries Clutton has been associated with coal mining from 1597 and the last mine closing in 1923. Fig. 1 below shows the known mines in Clutton.
MINING BEFORE 1754
The earliest reference to coal mining in Clutton is in a presentment dated 1597 which outlines a dispute involving a miner who did not fill in his disused coalpit. However, a more detailed account of mining at this time comes from a report on the Clutton manor dated 1610. This identified three pits by widow Blacker's house. Unfortunately it has not been possible to identify precisely the location of these pits, but the likely areas are Pennyquick and Greyfield Woods.
These pits were quite shallow, being four, six and eight fathoms deep, but the following description shows that they were extensive underground:
"they cut their lanes about four feet high and broad …"

These pits were quite shallow, being four, six and eight fathoms deep, but the following description shows that they were extensive underground:-
'they cut their lanes about four feet high and broad. They need no great store of timber for support. The lane we crept through was a good quoit cast in length wherein we found two cross lanes, whereby it may appear that the mine is newly entered into. At the end of each lane a man worketh and there maketh his bench and according to the vent they maketh more or fewer benches.'
This method, whereby pillars are left to support the mine, is certainly a progression on the earliest form of underground mining, that is a bell pit. (see Fig: 2) It is most likely that bell pits were used extensively in Clutton before the 1610 mines. Indeed there are numerous mounds in the fields around Clutton and old workings have been found in Greyfield Wood, in Coalpit Field at Frys Bottom and behind Maypole Farm. (see Fig: 1). The bell pits would have worked the coal seams that outcropped near to the surface.
The scale of production of the 1610 pits was small. The pits worked two at a time and employed two or three men underground, four or five carting boys and two or three men to wind up the coals using a simple windlass and bucket. The mines probably served a very limited local market.
Wages in 1610 were 4s. a week for a hewer and 1s 6d. a week for carting boys. Coal was sold for 3d per horse load which gave a pithead price of 1–1½d. per bushel. Total costs, including candles, rope, timber and wages came to £3 per week. The net gain was £4 10s., three quarters of which went to the lord.
Mining continued during this period for there are coalpit accounts dated 1663–71 and 1681–1691 in the Earl of Warwick's estate records. There are also mining leases dated 1688–94, 1739 and 1752. The 1663–71 accounts are mainly about money but it is possible to obtain some general information from them. This period appears to have been one of quite intense activity for there were 37 pits sunk.
The field evidence for many of these pits must have disappeared many years ago, but it is most likely that the shafts in the Pennyquick, North End and Nap Hill areas date from this era. (see Fig:1) The number of men employed varied between 10 and 16 each week and different men worked on successive weeks. Wages varied on a weekly basis, for example Thomas Naish Snr. was paid 10s 8d, 7s, 4s 8d, 5s 8d and 2s 10d for five different weeks in November and December of 1669. Probably the techniques used in these mines were very similar to those used in the 1610 mines. Unfortunately, though, it has not been possible to determine whether the mining activity before 1754 represents continuous or intermittant mining.
MINING BETWEEN 1754 and 1833
In 1754 a survey was conducted of the Earl of Warwick's estate and the only mining activity was at Redhill, where a Mr. Bolster was tenant. Therefore it would seem that the earlier activity had ceased. However, Churchlands came into use again in 1778/9 when freeshare was paid for coals dug there.
Mining at Clutton Hill marks the beginning of a period of continuous mining activity in Clutton which came to an end in 1923. The mines at Clutton Hill were in operation in 1793 and by the time of the 1836 estate survey they were disused.
These pits differ significantly from the earlier mines in that they are deeper and have lined shafts.
These mines differed in that there were several inclines or guggs away from the main shaft and each had a coalface of about 30 yards. This was called the 'longwall' method of mining and this meant that more men could be employed underground and more coal could be removed, although it did necessitate a greater amount of timber for supports. A horse gin would have been used to bring coal to the surface - See Figure 3.
The scale of production was altogether much larger. On average 60 men were employed and annual production would have varied between about 60,000 and 100,000 tons.
Indeed this area was something of a local industrial centre for there was a brickworks and a limekiln at Clutton Lower Works. The increase in the scale of production resulted from an expansion of the local market. The population was increasing, creating a demand for domestic coal. Inferior coals were used in the growing number of limekilns and brickworks. However, the market did not spread beyond the immediate locality due to the poor road system and the high cost of land carriage.
The proprietors of the Lower and Upper Works presented a petition in May 1789 outlining objections to an increase in turnpike tolls which would increase costs and allow an influx of cheaper coals from other coalfields.
Before 1754 the extent of the local market encouraged the development of small mining enterprises and the capital needed to start such a works was not beyond the means of a local yeoman. Indeed it was not uncommon for the working collier to be the colliery owner. However, with the increase in the size of production the costs had increased beyond the means of such a person. This resulted in small groups of local entrepreneurs of quite substantial means becoming involved in mining. This trend can be seen at the Clutton Works. Both Richard Moore and Joseph Brodribb were tenants of substantial farms in Clutton. The trend continued with the later developments at Greyfield and Frys Bottom which involved David Cook of North End Farm and James Rossiter of Cloud Hill Farm.
The mining accounts are, again, quite useful for obtaining information about the nature of mining. Wages were paid for the following jobs:- breakers, carting boys, gugg workers, for carting the dung, for tipping coal, blacksmith, carpenter, brickmaker and for loading the bricks. Wages at this time were on average 1s 8d per day for a breaker and 1s 3d per day for carting boys. An interesting feature of the accounts is that the underground workers were paid for working in teams which varied in size from 2 to 4 persons and that each group was paid according to how much coal was brought out.
Clutton Coal Works was in operation in 1817 as it is identified on the First Edition of the 1" to a mile Ordnance Survey map and was involved in a strike in February of that year. However, the works was closed by 1836. The decline and ultimate closure of these pits is probably related to the development of the Somerset Coal Canal. Different, cheaper, forms of transport were necessary to maintain the development of the coalfield and canals provided this. Mines connected to the canal tended to prosper while those not often declined. The Somerset Coal Canal Act of 1794 authorised six tramways to be connected to the canal head, including one to the Clutton Coal Works.
However, it was never completed as planned; a shorter tramway followed Timsbury Bottom and then forked, the two branches terminating at Amesbury and Mearns Pits. It has not been possible to determine, conclusively, whether this fact explains the demise of the Clutton Coal Works, but the later mines of Greyfield and Frys Bottom belong to the railway era.
MINING BETWEEN 1833 and 1923
During during this period centred on the pits at Greyfield, Frys Bottom and Burchills, though there were smaller pits in operation as well, for example Rudges and Perrys Pits. It was during this period that mining activity reached its peak in Clutton.
a. Greyfield Pit
Clutton New Coal Works, as Greyfield was first known, began its life in 1833 when the Earl of Warwick leased mineral rights. David Cook of North End Farm was the only local person amongst the shareholders. The other shareholders were John Savage Cameron of Eastbourne and Samuel Foster of Lincolns Inn, Middlesex thus showing that capital from outside the local area was being invested in coal mining in Clutton.
The New Coal Works was not the first to operate in the area around Greyfield Woods. The early bell pits have already been noted, but Old Greyfield Pit is found at the entrance to Greyfield Wood. The first shaft was square with wooden guides and wound by a steam engine. At first, owing to a lack of any road access to the pithead, a double track tramroad incline (and presumably a hauling engine) with a drum at its head was built from the colliery up to a coal depot on the Bath to High Littleton Road. me tramroad did not last long and soon the coal was moved through Greyfield Wood to Hallatrow Station.
The early years of the works were often difficult. A deed of 1842 stated that new monies were needed for a new 90hp engine, extensions to the existing shafts and new pumps. This necessitated a call of £1,000 on each share. Both Alexander Cameron Ford (nephew of John Cameron) and David Cook were unable to pay the necessary calls on their shares and became liable for gradually increasing debts. David Cook had to move from the substantial North End Farm to a small cottage on Clutton Hill and when he died in 1848 the Rees Mogg family acquired his shares as trustees of his estate. In fact by this time the Rees Moggs had become the major shareholders.
Output for the year 1846 was 11,900 tons, but the works went through a bad time in 1856. Charles Hollwey, the manager, wrote that 'the underground workings are very dismaying and the trade, with the exception of the gas contract, is scarcely worth mention.
Trade was still slack three years later, the first quarter of 1861 showing an income of £529 against an expenditure (excluding wages) of less than £200.
During the latter half of the 19th century there was extensive expansion and modernisation of the colliery. A further three shafts were sunk, the first was a coaling shaft 10ft in diameter, the second was for ventilation and the third was equipped with a Cornish Beam engine for pumping up water from the workings. In addition to the shafts there was a drift, running north-east, known as the Cuckoo Drift. (Cuckoo was a nickname for one of the coal veins) This drift led to the bottom of the shaft at Moorsland Colliery. Originally this led an independent existence, but the output was transferred to the Greyfield Coal Company. During this period the colliery shafts reached their maximum depth, 850 feet, and were working the Streak, Peacock, Dabchick and New Veins of the Upper Coal Series.
The hauling engines on the coaling shafts were repaired by the Paulton Foundry during the 1860's and a new engine was delivered in September, 1861 at a cost of £254. The Cornish Beam engine was also completely overhauled in April, 1861 for a cost of £350.
This mechanisation and expansion of the colliery helps to explain its growth, but probably the main reason was the introduction of a railway siding from the pithead connecting the colliery with the Bristol and North Somerset Railway at Clutton Station. Initially the coal trucks went under the influence of gravity to the station and were then pulled back by horses. The first locomotive was introduced in 1885 and had the name Francis, though it was familiarly known as The Coffee-Pot. In 1894 a new locomotive was introduced and was known as Daisy. This railway link made access to markets much easier and the colliery prospered, so much so that output had increased to 60,000 tons in 1889. The underground workings were extensive reaching the village.
There was an increase in the size of the labour force which necessitated new housing and in 1900 Maynard Terrace was built. Thus by the late 19th century Greyfield had become one of the most important collieries in Somerset. A general view of the colliery at this time can be seen in Fig: 4.
Greyfield ran into a number of difficulties in the early part of the 20th century. In 1904 the Cuckoo Drift and the Moorsland workings were abandoned. Then in 1909 the colliery was the scene of a major disaster when water from old workings broke into the Streak vein. There was no loss of life and the miners were soon back at work. However, by the end of the year some men were given notice due to the closure of an area of the workings. Worse was to come when, on 26th May, 1911, the whole colliery closed following royalty difficulties. This resulted in about 300 men being made redundant, but many of the men and the machines used were transferred to the newly opened Burchills Pit.
b. Frys Bottom Pit
It has not been possible to find a precise date for when work started at this pit, but it was in operation by the time of the 1836 Survey of the Earl of Warwick's estate. At this time James Rossiter, a local tenant farmer, was the main shareholder in the Frys Bottom Coal Company. Like Greyfield Pit, Frys Bottom Pit began mining in an area which had seen earlier activity. (see Fig: 1).

When the pit was first in operation a horse gin, similar to those used at the Clutton Hill Works, was used to provide power, but this system was superseded by a steam winding engine. The date of this change is uncertain, but a 4½ ton boiler was sold for scrap in 1862. The pit was connected to Clutton by a siding in 1864. Presumably, in the period preceding this the coal was removed from the pithead by horse and cart. Once the siding was in operation coal trucks could move under the influence of gravity to Clutton Station. Later on Coffee Pot was used to move the coal trucks to and from the station.
The pit mined the Streak, Hard, Sliving and Great veins of the Upper Coal Series and the shaft was 540 feet deep. The layout of the pit can be seen in Fig: 5.
Frys Bottom had a good safety record, for there was only one known accident in the pit. This occured on 8th July, 1867 when water from the older workings in the area flooded the pit. This cut off the air supply and Jabez Cook, aged 51, and George Collier, aged 14, died of suffocation. It appeared that the men had suspected danger because of the wetness of the coal. The manager ordered a boring to be made, but this proved inconclusive, so work continued. Soon after, though, the water broke through and the fatal accident occured.
The closure of Frys Bottom is something of a mystery. The men once petitioned for closure of the mine, though the reason for this is not recorded. Work was suspended in 1887 and the pit was permanently shut on 31st July, 1895. In 1897 the chimney was felled and Joseph Henry Cook was injured with broken ribs.
c. Burchills Pit
Burchills opened in 1911 soon after the closure of Greyfield Pit. Both Greyfield and Frys Bottom pits were situated some distance from the centre of the village, but Burchills was located in the village beside Batch Farm.
Work at Burchills actually began towards the end of 1908, the Clutton Coal Company, a subsidiary of the Greyfield Colliery Company, was formed and work began at two sites. The first site was next to Batch Farm where a drift was sunk following the inclination of the rocks. The second site was a few hundred yards to the north of the drift (see Fig: 1). An old shaft was reopened joining the bottom of the drift. The drift was used for access and for hauling coal for landsale and the shaft was connected to the railway and coal hauled here was for wider distribution. The Clutton Coal Company employed nearly 350 men and output was in excess of 780 tons per week.
However, there was always the constant fear that the new workings would cut into the old Greyfield workings and so flood the pit. The first rumours of closure came in 1918 when it was announced that the pit was to close in the near future and that the men would have to move to other pits. The Somerset Miners Association managed to come to an agreement with the Company and the mine remained open.
An inrush of water from the Greyfield workings flooded part of the pit on 27th April, 1920. The existing pumps were inadequate and the pit then only mined coal above the water level.
The end came in 1921. The company was in a very bad financial position and most of the coal reserves were exhausted, in fact there was not even enough coal to keep the colliery boilers in steam. On the 29th of August the Greyfield Company announced the closure of the pit and dismantling began. The men responded by offering to take whatever wages the pit would pay; the company agreed, but the Somerset Miners Association would not allow it and the men were forced to agree with their union. There then followed a period when Lady Warwick was involved in the discussions and there was talk of a workers co-operative and a new company, but nothing came of it and the final dismantling of the underground workings was completed by 11th October, 1921.
d. Nap Hill Adit
This small drift mine opened soon after the closure of Burchills and was located behind the spoil heaps of that pit. The mine was only open for a short while, closing in March, 1923. Little is known about this mine, whether a great deal of coal was brought to the surface or how many men were employed.
e. Rudges Pit
This pit was sunk in 1847, but was closed by 1854. The pit had achieved an output of less than 90 tons of coal per week.
Exploration in 1918 had suggested that the Rudge seam was of high quality and in April, 1923 a new mine was proposed to work this seam in areas missed by the old Rudges Pit. It was intended to lease 200 acres of coal south of the village and drive a pair of drifts down to the seam, using one of the Rudges Pit shafts for ventilation. This proposed Cloud Hill colliery failed before it began, the optimism regarding the Rudge seam being ill-founded.
Thus with the failure of the Cloud Hill venture coal mining came to end in Clutton. Mining had been going on for over 300 years in the village and impinged upon the lives of many, if not all, Cluttonians past and present.
SOURCES
Atthill, R., 'When 30 pits were working in Somerset and tramroads fed the coal canal', Somerset Guardian, 1963.
Bluhm, R. K., Bibliography of the Somerset Coalfield 1968.
Bulley, J. A., 'To Mendip for coal': a study of the Somerset Coalfield before 1830, Somerset Archaeology and Natural History, 97, 46–78; 98, 17–54.
Clew, K., The Somersetshire Coal Canal and Railways (Newton Abbott) 1971.
Clutton Womens Institute, The Story of our village.
Down, C. D. and Warrington, A. S., The History of the Somerset Coalfield (Newton Abbott) 1971.
Earl of Warwick's Estate records held in Warwick Record Office.
Griffin, A. R., The Collier (Shire) 1982.
Lewis, M. J. T. Early Wooden Railways, 1970.
NCB records.
Somerset Record Office
Clutton Tithe map 1838.
1854 survey of the Earl of Warwick's Estate.
Wells, W. C. Historical Review of the Bristol and Somerset Coalfields (Mardons) 1977.



